What Island Is Your Dream Girl From [POLL]

Kenny Chesney's new hit is called, "Pirate Flag."

The chorus of the song has Kenny singing:

I spent my whole life running around
Still let the wind kinda blow me around
Well I dropped a note in a bottle
To a long-legged model
And I traded it in for a whole 'nother world
A pirate flag and an island girl

That got me wondering....If you traded it all for a pirate flag and an island girl.....which island would your girl be from?

I'm assuming your island girl is from South Jersey of course!

Technically, some of the choices below may not be actual islands - but, they're by the water, so I'm counting them!