It would seem that someone out in the media cosmos is randomly throwing out potential beaus for admittedly — nay, adamantly — single country sweetheart Taylor Swift, and each time they’re catching like wildfire. The teen sensation likely doesn’t have enough hours in the day to deflect all the dating rumors that have been thrown her way as of late. Every time she talks to a guy, meets him for dinner or glances up in his direction, she’s smacked with a dating question mark. And this time, her suspected match is NFL star Tim Tebow.

Perhaps this is just wishful thinking for a fanbase that’s not too keen on a single Swift? Who knows, but whatever the case, questions about Tebow and Swift’s potentially budding relationship are taking over the internet today. ClevverTV (via Ace Showbiz) is reporting that the two dined together Monday night at L.A.’s Toscanova Italian restaurant, and what’s more, that the two entered together.

“After dinner, he walked her out,” a source told the website. “Then he walked back in to join two other people. I think they may both have been with their agents.” Doesn’t exactly sound like a romantic dinner for two, but it was enough to raise eyebrows nonetheless. Adding more fodder to the quickly spreading chatter is the fact that the two were seen talking at the WME pre-Oscar party on Feb. 24. Incriminating evidence, indeed.

This all comes on the heels of a good bit of talk that Taylor Swift had become romantically interested in her ‘The Lorax’ costar Zac Efron, which the star quickly laughed off. Regardless of what anyone says today, according to an interview by some of the youngest TV hosts around — Ellen DeGeneres’ little YouTube sensations Sophia Grace and Rosie — Swift is still very much without a boyfriend.